Howard
J. Sewell
The Ideal Audience
Isn't Who You Think
(DM News, September 13, 1999)
Perhaps it's a function of our Internet-driven world
that makes everything from Grandma to groceries just
a mouse click away. Whatever the reason, high-tech companies
are obsessed with short-cutting the sales process.
From Web sites to sales automation, the abdication of
the sales role to technology and sales reps' "don't
call us until you're ready to buy" attitude inevitably
trickles down to impact a company's direct marketing
strategy. For an agency, this often materializes as
a directive to "target the decision makers."
Spurred by the mandate to target people based on little
more than check-writing authority, many high-tech companies
(and their agencies) embark on campaigns on the "golf-ball-in-a-box"
theme. You know the type - "Company X mailed a
set of gold-plated golf balls in a custom-manufactured
marble box to 600 top executives and generated a phenomenal
25 percent response." These campaigns get showered in
awards (they're so innovative! they're so creative!)
but rarely succeed in generating the genuine business
opportunities for which they were intended - least
of all on a cost-per-lead basis.
Focusing marketing dollars on reaching decision makers
may seem efficient, but it's usually just the opposite.
In fact, top-down marketing presents two fundamental
challenges:
Problem
#1: Decision makers are hard to reach. They have
more demands on their time, more distractions and more
"screens" (the mail clerk, the department secretary,
the executive assistant) who may prevent them from even
receiving your message.
Problem
#2: Decision makers don't always "feel the pain" that
your technology can help solve. CIOs may have signing
authority for your $250,000 Customer Relationship Management
system, but on a daily basis, are they grappling with
the problems that your software can help solve? Probably
not. And that makes it less likely that your message
will resonate with them in the first place.
The
result: In their drive to streamline the sales process,
companies are leaving a lot of leads (and potential
customers) on the table. Here are a couple of proposed
solutions:
Solution
#1: Don't shortcut the process. Let your sales force
do the selling. (That's what you're paying them for.)
Advances in Web technology notwithstanding, no one has
invented the direct marketing campaign or Web site that
can answer questions, handle objections, probe for needs
and close the sale better than a live human being. Sure,
we'd all like direct marketing to do the job for us,
but in the technology business (unless you're Michael
Dell), it rarely works that way.
Solution
#2: Broaden your scope. Don't limit yourself to
the executive suite. Think of direct marketing as a
means to identify organizations with the problem your
technology can solve, no matter what job title the caller
has on his or her business card. Sure it's more work
for your sales force. But the people who are ready to
buy will respond regardless, and in the meantime you'll
also generate leads from a much larger spectrum of potential
customers who have the problem you can solve and want
to do something about it. If that's not a good lead,
what is?
How low should you go? As a general rule, target the
highest level in the organization at which the problem
is understood. Don't aim so high that your prospect
doesn't grapple with the issues that your technology
addresses. But don't aim so low that your contact doesn't
have the means or influence to evangelize your product.
Choose carefully, and you'll not only minimize your
sales cycle by entering at the optimal point in the
corporate hierarchy, but also maximize results by targeting
the people with whom your message will best resonate.
Finally, test. Direct marketing is measurable, so use
that to your advantage. Test CIOs against application
developers, for example, and gauge which group generates
a higher response and more sales. Ultimately, you may
find that your ideal audience works in a cube -
not the corner office.