September 2001
TARGETING END USERS VS.
DECISION-MAKERS
We recently executed an online campaign for a software application
that improves Web site functionality and helps drive Web visitors
to a company's brick-and-mortar locations (reducing the load on
corporate call centers).
We targeted two groups: 1) call center managers and other
business titles, and 2) webmasters, content managers and other
technical titles. Each group received a message tailored to the
particular pain points (and benefits) most relevant to that
audience.
The results were surprising, if not unprecedented. The call
center/business group performed at far better rates than did the
Web/technical audience, so much so that in a follow-up campaign
now in development, we're dropping the Web audience entirely.
This highlights a challenge that many high-tech companies face,
namely: do we target the group that actually uses the technology
and derives a personal or business benefit from it, or do we target
the group that's responsible for sourcing, evaluating and approving
the purchase of the product?
The difference in response rate is seldom dramatic, but more times
than not, we see better numbers from the end-user audience. It's
not hard to see why. A business manager is more likely to be "feeling
the pain" that a particular product or service solves, and therefore
is more inclined to request information on how to solve that problem.
An IT manager or other technical decision-maker may well be the
person that would ultimately approve the purchase, but he or she
may not be dealing with the relevant issues or problems on a
day-to-day basis, and therefore is less likely to respond.
Particularly in today's economic climate, there's a tendency to
want to target the decision-maker as much as possible, in order to
close deals more quickly (in theory, anyway). Occasionally that
makes sense, but only if that decision-maker is feeling the right
"pain" such that your message will resonate with him or her.
Targeting end users may extend the sales cycle, but it's also likely
to generate a larger number of genuine sales opportunities -
that is, companies or individuals with the problem that you can
solve.
As always, the best option is to test. Split the audience into
different categories, code the responses accordingly, and gauge
what works best for your particular product or service.